« When You Gotta Hava Wawa | Main | Cream of Green Soup »

January 29, 2007

And The Winners Are...

A few weeks ago, I posted an essay contest. The question was, "Why are people so hateful about CR?"

Thanks to all for your thoughtful responses. I enjoyed reading them all. But I had to choose, so here are the winners. Remember, these are reader submissions. I agree with some things written, and disagree with other things.

Second runner up: Robin.

When you are afraid, it actually takes courage to recognize your fear and give it its proper name. For some reason, it's more socially acceptable to express anger or even hatred than it is to admit your fears. In the end, there are only two responses to fear: fight or flight.

Those of us who have started down the CR path are admitting that we fear death and disease, and we want to do everything in our power to avoid those things as long as possible. We are the fighters. Those who attack us are also afraid of death and disease. But instead of confronting those fears, they reach for anger and hatred - emotions that are apparently easier for them to feel than fear.

This does not apply to everyone who disagrees with CR. There are many scientific and moral issues surrounding CR that deserve proper consideration and debate. If this is done honestly and with respect, I think everyone wins. But the folks who resort to personal attacks and pronounce death wishes on those who practice CR leave no room for discussion. These people only pretend to be fighting. What they're actually doing is running away from their own terrors.

First runner up: Nerissa.

Here is my entire essay:

People don't like seeing other people happy when they
are not happy.

And the winner is: A. Meeks, with:

No Sympathy for the Skinny

We are told to embrace ourselves and love ourselves. It's not such a
hard message when you like what you see in the mirror. The week I
turned 25, I did not like what I saw in the mirror. I started writing
down what I was eating every day and making better choices. I was at a
healthy weight, according to the numbers, but I wanted to see what I
could do to truly feel comfortable with my own body.

I realized, after telling one girl friend what I was up to, in what I
thought was a sympathetic "we're in this together" moment, that I had
made a mistake in advertising it to anyone. Although she was trying to
start a diet herself, she was aghast that I was trying to lose weight.
I realized if I told anyone else I would be met with that American
shriek of "you don't need to lose WEIGHT!" and immediate gossip about
an eating disorder. Even my father, who has been slowly and steadily
losing weight because of the same concerns as me, and has gone from 6'
and more than 200 pounds down to 175 over about the last year, joked,
"You aimin' for the double-digits?"

Oh, the cheap, sensationalist flourish of "eating disorders." As a
former teenage American girl, I only saw the eating disorder world
through my acquaintances and friends, not in my own life. The most
predominate eating disorder I saw was compulsive eating. I knew only
one true anoretic and one real combination anoretic/bulimic. And there
were some who claimed years after the fact, after having gained
massive weight, that when they were at normal weights it was only
because they had an eating disorder. Thereby making their obesity
healthy, because it meant they had escaped their so-called eating
disorder.

America has turned into a country where the merest flutter of hunger
is a discomfort on the level of heroin withdrawl. The 65 percent of
Americans who are overweight/obese can call themselves healthy
because they have "escaped" an eating disorder, something that affects
about one percent of adolescent girls. Yet as overweight people who
have come to grips about their relationships with food will tell you
(the authors of Body Clutter, for example), those 65 percent of
Americans are quite unhappy.

Ours is a country where depression is treated with macaroni and
cheese, chocolate, french fries, and 3-liter bottles of Coca Cola. Get
rid of that treatment and you have pain. Obesity is a way for people
to drug and shield themselves from jealousy, from attention, even from
- as in the case when I lived with two obese girls in college and was
expected to be the one to run upstairs and fetch things - expectation.

Much in the same way someone with a broken soul will approach the
pulpit to be saved at a Baptist service, being large is a way to tell
the world that you are in pain, a martyr. It is a way to get a husband
you don't really love not to want to reach out to you in bed. It is a
way to excuse lack of speed. Now, as this state of bodily affairs is
the majority, it is a way to disappear into the crowd.

American corporations, from the drive-through fast food establishments
to the burgeoning industry of plus-size clothiers, have discovered
that there's mad cash to be made off it. One has to have put forth the
effort to clean out their psyche, before one can attempt the simple
exercise of caloric investment banking. I don't have any debt, nor do
I want it. And I don't want to have any excess storage meant for
previous generations of humans' genetics.

It's January now, when the females in offices across America come in
during their lunch breaks, hands full of crinkly Wendy's and
Whataburger and McDonald's and Sonic bags, vats of
high-fructose corn syrup in their hands, and lament to each other
about should they try and sign up for Curves this year?

I remember what it was like to weigh 25 more pounds than I weigh now
and to be unhappy, heaviness causing the sadness as much as the other
caused the other, and it seems impossibly sad to watch people your own
age go down a totally avoidable path if they just would get straight
in their own heads.

Why do I think people are so virulently against CR? In a country where
the average American woman is a size 14, even adjusted for vanity
sizing, it's an easy target. While CR could easily put on a pious
front, it is, these days, the fat that reserve that for themselves.

Watch a taped performance from 25 years ago, one with frequent shots
of audience members enjoying the actors. Watch one today. The face of
America is changing. It has a double chin and the upper body of a
long-former linebacker. And if you're not with the expanding beltline,
you're against it.

Posted by: A. Meeks at January 8, 2007 4:06 PM

Posted by april at January 29, 2007 4:44 PM

Comments

...and also, we want to take your chocolate chip cookies away.

Posted by: A. Meeks/allswellinhell at January 29, 2007 3:05 PM

Excellent post....congrats to the winner. Well deserved! Hey, with that kind of writing....you can have the darn cookies! GREAT JOB!

Posted by: carolyn at January 29, 2007 3:37 PM

What a relief to read an essay like that, I completely agree with A. Meeks. 'Skinnyness' or 'weight loss' such a taboo subject- and it's nice to see someone broach it honestly, fearlessly and intelligently like that. Thanks!

Posted by: Hazel at January 29, 2007 6:25 PM

Hi April
I would be really interested in hearing more about what A. Meeks has to say about the author of Body Clutter. I subscribe to the emails of the Fly Lady, the author, because they motivate me to keep my apartment clean. When the author wrote a book called Body Clutter, I bought one, hoping to give it to my morbidly obese sister. I read it and find it a bit light. While I respect Fly Lady's capacity to inspire people to manage their households, I'm a bit bothered to discover that she must be about 30 in BMI, based on her pictures taken with her favorite musician. I just don't feel I want to give my sister a book on nutrition written by someone who appears to be really overweight. I feel it might have the opposite effect than the one I want. My sister may just accept herself and do nothing. To be honest, my sister is at that level already, in great denial of her bad health. It reminds me of another CR person who complained of a famous self help psychologist writing a book on dieting, when it appears that the doctor himself should be on a diet. Cheers, Arturo

Posted by: Arturo at January 29, 2007 10:16 PM

Arturo,
Yeah, that bugs me too. I did an image search yesterday on both of them, though, and it seems like they've have lost *some* weight since the first pictures I saw of them. Frankly, I think they're, at least a little bit, kowtowing to the crowd of mostly obese housewives who follow their services, because they're already so fragile that a full-out RANT on their butts would destroy them. But, I mean, there's this whole emphasis they have on "Finally Loving Yourself" which I think is bunk too. It's like "Mindless Eating." You take the good parts from it and when society pats you on the head and says "it's okay if you're a size 14, honey, just as long as you love yourself" just have the presence of mind to go: No. That's Bullshit.

Even if their own lives are messed up (it seems they're at least trying to get themselves back on track) they did come up with some good, honest condemnations of their own excuses and fat tuchuses. I like Dr. Laura's radio show even though it's pretty well known she's nuts. I think Tom Cruise is a fine actor, even though he's a freakjob. And I think both Michael Jackson and Britney Spears have made some of the best popsongs of our time. It may be hypocritical for their message if FlyLady's chunky, but these days, with this accountability, who's not a hypocrite? I think Cardinal Richelieu said something about that, but I'm late for work...

Posted by: Allswellinhell/Meeks at January 30, 2007 9:03 AM

Hi, April.

Interesting choice of winner. I actually think Robin's appears most like what a CRON practitioner probably thinks.

Congratulations, Mister Meeks. Your grasp of the written word is startling.

Take care, April.

-Noah

Posted by: Noah at February 1, 2007 3:11 AM

You're quite welcome, Miss Noah! ; )

-Mrs. Meeks

Posted by: allswellinhell at February 1, 2007 8:49 PM

OK, allswellinhell.

Allow me to offer you a bit of advice. Remember to eat your vegetables, son.

Be well,

-Noah

Posted by: Noah at February 2, 2007 3:14 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?


Preview Post